THE GREATEST COMICS OF ALL TIME: Animal Man #19-26

Posted on February 10th, 2012 by ekko

Grant MorrisonI am by no means a person who says that Grant Morrison can do no wrong.  I don’t even think his entire Animal Man run reaches the “brilliant” level.  The first five issues, yes, were unlike anything that came before.  And the eight issues I am reviewing today: Revolutionary.  But in the middle act, it did lag a little bit.

But today I am here to praise Grant’s Animal Man, not bury it.  And you kind of need to read all 26 issues to get the full impact of this last arc.

At the risk of “spoiling” this story, I’m going to write about a few details.  But not enough to give the whole thing away.  Still, if my word is enough to get you to go buy this then stop reading now.

Ahem.

Now that we’re alone….

The last large arc on Morrison’s work with Animal Man can really be bifurcated into two parts: The gruesome and powerful slaughter of Buddy Baker’s family, and his psychological and emotional reaction to it, and then his “super hero” reaction to it.  In the first half of the story, we see how Buddy’s family’s murder leads him to become vengeful and angry, so much so that he eventually seeks revenge.  But before that, we get to see his denial chipping away at him, through inner dialog in which he personifies his own memories and begins to reimagine/reinterpret his own origin.  We get to see him, psychologically, retconning himself.  And Morrison’s entire take on this B-list DC supercharacter was a retcon to begin with.  So it’s a bit of a head trip.  But it’s also genuinely impactful on a gut level.

Then, to add another level, Animal Man goes and gets himself a time machine and begins to literally retcon himself, with the help of a ton of DC characters who are know for being able to reshape time and psyches (Psycho Pirate, Rip Hunter, Phantom Stranger, etc.) and heroes from various alternate Earths as well, until eventually he shatters the fourth wall and realizes that he is in a comic book–a giant “monkey puzzle,” in which everything can be fit together in a head-spinning swirl.  Everything that happened in the issues preceding these is rediscovered and revised–much like Morrison has done with JLA, Batman and other characters throughout his career.

I won’t give away the very end, but it’s fantastic–and you will not see it coming.

This is probably my favorite Grant Morrison super-hero story of all time.

WALT SIMONSON TAKES ON THE AVENGERS…And other news.

Posted on January 15th, 2012 by ekko

As artist only, the writer/artist who created Frog Thor and Beta Ray Bill will be the new regular artist for the Brian Michael Bendis written Avengers book, beginning with issue #25. Of course, with Bendis promising to leave The Avengers this year, could it be Walt is prepping for a larger role? One can only hope, as Simonson’s imagination has led to some brilliant work in the past, such as:

· The afore-mentioned creation of Beta Ray Bill and Frog Thor, and a long run on Thor that split Don Blake and Thor for the first time, brought Ragnarok, and introduced Asgardian warriors to the wonders of automatic weapons.

· With his wife, an X-Factor run that introduced Cable and Mr. Sinister.

· The artwork on X-Men/Teen Titans, the greatest Marvel-DC crossover ever.

· A tremendous run on The Fantastic Four that replaced the foursome with Ghost Rider, Hulk, Spidey and Wolverine.

· Award winning issues of Detective Comics, during the 1974 event “The Manhunter Saga.”

For more on the world of comics, including the rundown on new and cancelled DC titles, hit the break….

Read the rest of this entry »

COMIC BOOK SALES FOR NOVEMBER 2011

Posted on December 12th, 2011 by ekko

DC copped 40% issues sold, Marvel got 38%.  Of course, DC is down a lot.  22% to be exact.  But that’s totally to be expected, with the media push and 52 #1s in one month.  I’d expect a little more downturn in the coming months.  They’re still up from their pre-New 52 market share, but my prediction is that in a few months they’ll be back where they were before the whole relaunch.  Does that mean it wasn’t worth it?  Of course not.  Those few months of big sales were BIG sales for DC—and the amount of hype and publicity they got can only be good for those of us who love comics.  It’s probably due solely to the New 52 that overall comic sales are up 7% for the year—the first rise in yearly figures in two years.

The top 10 titles were still mostly DC: Justice League #3 led the pack, followed by #3s of Batman, Action, and Green Lantern.  Interestingly, Marvel’s “Point One” book came in at #5—it had a $6 price tag and generally got bad reviews.  (All filler!  No meat!)  I’m sure that helped Marvel’s dollar sales figs significantly.  Also interesting: #6 in November 2011’s top 10 was the new Avenging Spider-Man title.  I’m hoping that book is a hit, as I was always a big fan of Marvel Team-Up.
Rounding out the bottom four of the top 10, beginning at #7, were Uncanny X-Men #1, Detective #3, Flash #3 and, finally, Wolverine and the X-Men #2.

A bigger shock to me was what the New 52 continues to do for DC’s OGN/Trade Paperback sales.  I thought the reboot essentially killed off their back issue market, since the New 52 meant the old stories no longer mattered. But DC had half of the top 10 paperbacks sold last month—in a pre-Christmas month that found graphic novel sales up 30% from October.  A good month for trades!  I’m also very, very glad to see Joe the Barbarian in the top 10.  I know I had something to do with that—I bought two copies.

Here’s your top 10 trades.  Note the complete absence of anything Marvel—despite their release of the amazing John Byrne Fantastic Four Omnibus.

10. Joe the Barbarian (DC/Vertigo)
9. BPRD: Being Human (Dark Horse)
8. Sailor Moon Vol. 2
7.  Green Lantern: War of the Green Lanterns (DC)
6.  Scalped Vol. 8 (DC/Vertigo)
5.  Batman and Robin Vol. 2 (DC)
4.  The Walking Dead Vol. 1 (reissue) (Image)
3.  The Boys Vol. 9 (Dynamite)
2.  Hellboy: House of the Living Dead (Dark Horse)
1.  Batman: Noel Deluxe Edition (DC)

Daredevil vs. Mole Man by Paolo Rivera. You can get me this original art for my birthday or Christmas or just 'cause you love me.

THE TOP 100 COMIC BOOK HEROES OF ALL TIME

Posted on December 5th, 2011 by ekko

IGN published a top 100 comic book heroes that made me crazy, both in its predictability (Hey! Superman and Bats are #s 1 and 2!), overinclusiveness (every single Robin except Damian Wayne (who is the most interesting one by far), as well as Superboy and Supergirl?  Really?) and its attempts to be esoteric without providing sufficient justification (Groo makes the list, but they don’t really say what makes him so essential; James Gordon makes the list, but Aunt May and Uncle Ben don’t–nor does Jarvis; and Nova makes the list, but nobody really gives a shit about Nova).  Maybe it was the list’s sketchy criteria for placement: “Picked by their cultural impact, character development, social relevance, general cool factor, and importance of storylines, these are the best of the best.

It made me so nuts, I made my own list.  Yes, there’s a lot of overlap.  But mine is better.  Because I said so.

Note: If you’re just looking for a list without supporting arguments, you can jump to the last page of this post.  But you can’t tell me I was wrong to put Thor at #33 unless you go and read why.  So, read every page and then tell me why I’m full of $#!+.

Enjoy!

Read the rest of this entry »

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40

RANKING THE NEW 52…

Posted on October 2nd, 2011 by ekko
So, the new 52 is out.  Was it worth it? 
Well, for one thing, they got me interested enough to check out more than half of what they published in a month.  Usually, I have maybe 3 DC books on my regular pull list and a few more that I check out in trade.  So that’s a good source of adrenaline for the publisher.  Now, they need to keep my interest.
My local comics dealer was thrilled at the increased sales but also said, “We’ll see how they’re doing around issue #4.”  As for the #1s, every single one is a sell-out according to DC.  All will get second printings, even Legion Lost, and some have third (Action, Batgirl) and even fourth (Justice League) printings.  (JL is also the best-selling book of all 2011.  No big surprise there.)  In case you’re really (nerdy) curious, it takes sales in excess of 100K to sell out a comic book print run.  Putting that in perspective, the average NY Times bestselling book sells about 3K (but costs about $25, versus $3 for a comic.)
The ultimate question, really, is whether the new titles are any better than the ones they replaced.  DC can dick around with characters’ detailed pasts, or whether they wear T-shirts or armor, but in the end if the books ain’t better, why should we care?
Here’s most of the 52, rated and ranked by a Marvel fan….After the cut.

THE NEW 52…

Posted on September 11th, 2011 by ekko
  • The JSA doesn’t exist in “our” world—they’re going to get their own Earth-2 series.
  • Vertigo exists in our world…Except when it doesn’t.  Swamp Thing and Constantine are here—but it’s not clear whether the “Sweet Tooth” world will be explained and “fit in” to the new DCU.  I always assumed Swampy and Consty were already in the DCU, and Vertigo was just a line to tell more mature stories about them.  Shows what I know.
  • Batman “hasn’t changed,” except that he has…He’s much more like Frank Miller’s All Star Batman, apparently, at least when Geoff Johns is writing him. Oh, and he has super-powers.  Or at least super armor.  Because in JL#1 ,he leaps “twenty feet.”
  • Cyborg isn’t a Teen Titan.  Or is he?  He’s a founding member of the Justice League, at least, which takes place 5 years ago.  I guess we’ll see what happens when Titans launches.  All I know is, I just ordered the Wolfman/Perez New Teen Titans Omnibus, so no matter how Geoff Johns reorganizes/erases the DCU, he’ll never get those stories off of my shelf!
  • The “beyond” universe will expand.  I’m pretty sure this is an alternate Earth thing.  But anway, we’ll see Superman Beyond and we’re promised “other” books as well.  I’m sure CD is happy to read that.  I know he’s a fan of Batman Beyond.
  • The aforementioned JSA and Beyond books will be part of a second launch—books that will replace underperforming books from the first launch.  So, basically, Dan DiDio produced 52 new titles and is already planning for their failure.  Niiiiiiice.
  • Raven isn’t in the Titans, but will get a miniseries.  A Teen Titans book without Raven?  That’s like a lollipop with no stick!
  • The new Green Arrow looks like the Green Arrow from the Smallville TV show, and feels a lot like 1960s Batman.  Also, he looks kinda gay.  Actually, he kinda always looked gay.  (Not that there’s anything wrong with that.)
  • Scott Snyder hasn’t lost his knack for exciting arc-openers: Swamp Thing #1 began with a plague killing wildlife around the world, and Batman #1 shows us a person impaled to a wall by dozens of knives.  Neither beats the dead whale on the bank floor, but they’re still pretty damn good.
  • Superman’s got an edge to him, which makes him (gasp!) actually interesting.

MY TOP 10 COMIC BOOK WRITERS OF ALL TIME.

Posted on July 25th, 2011 by ekko

This will NOT qualify as the best writing...

Caveats:

One: If I already listed the creator as one of the best writer/artists, then I didn’t include them again. Seems only fair to let everyone else have a turn.

Two: I know that lots of folks are missing. To get on this list, the writer has to have a large, solid body of work with few misses. That’s why Jason Aaron and Matt Fraction aren’t here: Not a good enough hits-to-misses ratio. And their work has to have been impactful on the industry.

Three: If you disagree with me, please drop me a comment. But try to make it more intelligent than “Ekko, you suck!”  Remember, this is my list, not yours.  But I’d love to see who you think belongs here…

Four: Don’t bother telling me that Gardner Fox, Mark Millar, Marv Wolfman, JM DeMatteis, etc., should have made the list. I agree. I’m all broken up about it, too, but I had to narrow it down to ten because ten is how all the cool kids number their lists.

Five: Peter David is more literary than any author on this list, in that he uses many novelistic conventions and emphasizes character development over plot. This is especially true of his later work on X-Factor, which is probably the best-written comic book currently on the market in terms of individual characterization. David truly establishes a unique voice for every one of his characters. Still, he hasn’t produced enough superb work to get on the list. But when he loves his subject, there is truly no better character-and-dialog writer working today. So he gets his own caveat.

Hit the break for the big ten.

Read the rest of this entry »

THE TOP 10 COMIC BOOK WRITER/ARTISTS OF ALL TIME

Posted on July 23rd, 2011 by ekko
For kicks and giggles, I’m assembling my list of the top comic book writers of all time.  And as I go through the names, I realize that so few of them were also able to draw their own words.  So I thought I’d do this list as a prelude: The best comic book writer-artists of all time.  Plus, this helps me take some names off the best writers list that I’m working on, ‘cause they’re already here.
Hit the break.

THE JUNE IN COMIC BOOK TRADES

Posted on June 30th, 2011 by ekko

What to buy, what not to buy from the past month.

WHAT TO BUY: THE TOP 5 TRADES OF JUNE 2011

These get a 100 percent solid recommendation from this city corner of the interwebs:

Honorable mention:  X-Men: Second Coming.  This gets  a mention because it’s a lot of fun.  The tale of Hope coming to the present from the future, to save all mutants.  It sounds stupid, I know, but this is where the X-Men work best: In a straight-shot storyline where there’s lots of doom and gloom and lasers and all kinds of battling.  It’s basically a long-form brawl, and if you’ve not kept up with the mutant line, you can easily jump in here.

5.  Baltimore Volume 1: The Plague Ships. Mike Mignola and Christopher Golden introduced Lord Henry Baltimore back in 2007, but now he’s got his own series.  One of the best-selling indie books of the year (#1 sold out, even though it was also offered for free comic book day).  After Lord Baltimore unwittingly releases a horde of vampires, he goes searching to destroy their leader.  Gothic steampunk horror.

4.  Marvel Universe vs. The Punisher. A miniseries that could have gone horribly wrong goes wonderfully right.  Hilarious, action-packed, and featuring some of the best Deadpool stuff I’ve ever read.  Written by Jonathan Mayberry and illustrated by Goran “PunisherMAX” Parlov.  Chris borrowed my copy of the hardcover, and still hasn’t read it.  Shame on him.  Go on, everyone shame him.  Oh, and also on sale this week (6/29) is the sequel: Marvel Universe vs. Wolverine.  Mmmmm.  Good stuff.

3.  Uncanny X-Force: Deathlok Nation (hardcover). You can wait for the paperback, if you like, but don’t sleep on this, the best X-book around.  When Jason Aaron tried to bring Deathlok back in the pages of Wolverine, it sucked.  This doesn’t.  Plus, it builds on threads extending to the first appearances of Fantomex (in Grant Morrison’s New X-Men, which is mentioned all over this post!)   Featuring Deathlok versions of Captain America, Spider-Man, Elektra, Cyclops, Venom . . . A whole buncha cool stuff.  Plus, they throw in a reprint of Deathlok’s first appearance in Astonishing Tales #25 (1974).

2.  Sweet Tooth Vol. 3: Animal Armies. If you aren’t reading this book, you’re missing one of the best Vertigo books of all time.  Truly.  It’s spooky, odd, quirky, and touching.  And Chris, if you still haven’t read the trades I loaned you: Shame on you!

1.  Batwoman: Elegy. Possibly the most visually arresting comic book produced by one of the big two in the past 10 years.  The story can be a little confusing, but it’s well worth paying attention to.  I had to post some of the interior art here–just to let you see the kind of innovative design you’re missing.

THE TOP 5 REISSUES OF JUNE 2011

In addition to some trades of recently created comic books, check out these blasts from the past:

5.  The Boys Definitive Edition Vol. 3.  Yes, these issues have already appeared in trade paperbacks, and yes $75 is a lot of money.  But this is oversized and hardbound.  Darick Robertson’s art is worth it, don’t you think?

4.  The Impossible Man.  Everyone’s favorite imp, in every appearance drawn by Jack Kirby.  It includes his first appearance in Fantastic 4 #11 (written by Stan the Man), his best appearance in FF #176, my favorite issue of Spider Woman (#45, from 1978), and the best X-Men Annual ever (#7).  Among other things.  Yes, the late 1970s through the mid 1980s were a fantastic time to be reading comics.

3.  New X-Men by Grant Morrison Book 2. The only flaw in this is that it’s “digest sized”—slightly smaller than the average comic book.  But I’ve always said that Morrison’s New X-Men run was about the words, not the pictures.  (Although the issues drawn by Frank Quietly are pretty good, they’re not his best—and I’m not a big Ethan Van Sciver fan.)

2.  Daredevil: Yellow. From the days when the name Jeph Loeb meant something, with art by one of the best: Tim Sale.

1.  Creepy Comics Vol. 1. Reprinting the first four issues of Dark Horse’s reboot of the pre-code horror title, and featuring the work of folks like Doug Moench, Bernie Wrightson, Angelo Torres, Mike Woods, and Jason Shawn Alexander, among many others.  I saw this at my local shop (Victory Comics in Falls Church—holla!) and almost bought it immediately.  But then I remembered I needed to have money for dinner that night.  Maybe next time.

ONE  I WANNA BUY, BUT DON’T KNOW MUCH ABOUT:

Osborn: Evil Incarcerated. The story of Norman’s life in prison.  I don’t know much about it, but I love the writer (Kelly Sue DeConnick, who wrote the under-read and under-rated Sif miniseries) and the artist (Emma Rios, who is freaking amazing).

THREE NOT TO BUY

Spider-Man: The Original Clone Saga.  The only Spidey story so bad they had to re-make it.  Seriously, this is terrible.  Don’t even be curious.

Daredevil: Reborn. Because Shadowland wasn’t enough to convince Marvel to kick Andy Diggle off of this title.

Uncanny X-Men: Quarantine. Okay, this actually isn’t a horrible book, but what makes me crazy is that Marvel thinks I have amnesia.  Am I supposed to completely ignore the fact that Grant Morrison did a virtually identical storyline in New X-Men?  Wait.  How could I forget that, when Marvel is reprinting New X-Men this very month (see above)!!!  And most importantly, how could Cyclops forget it?!?

A FEW COMIC BOOK REVIEWS….

Posted on May 12th, 2011 by ekko

FEAR ITSELF #2. So we’re two issues in to Marvel’s latest event, and in this issue we see Odin imprison Thor (again). It’s a little hard to follow why Thor and Odin keep clashing, and honestly this latest one seems manufactured to match up with where Thor is at in his maturity in the movie—rather than to account for all the wisdom he really ought to have by now in the comic, from his commuppance long ago at the hands of Beta Ray Bill to the recent fall of Asgard and his voluntarily relinquishing the throne. Plus, there was a lot of set-up in this issue (setting up each villain, presumably so that they can go spin-off into other series). I was okay with this kind of exposition before, in the “prelude” and in issue #1, but it’s time to move the story forward. It’s starting to look more like a money grab—much like Shadowland—than a real event with something to say. Plus the story itself—global threat, heroes must go fight high-powered baddies-feels very “been there, done that.” There’s no mystery (like in Secret Invasion) or promise of major, important change (like House of M, Civil War).

If they don’t get rocking on this one soon, I’ll consider my lesson learned and never buy an event title again—at least not in loose issue form (I’ll wait for trades). I even bought the first issue of the Spider-Man spin off mini, because the creative team looked promising. Don’t let me down, Marvel. Not so soon after killing my wallet and faith with Shadowland.

 

BATMAN INC. #5. This is the first Grant Morrison story in Batman Inc.—and the first Morrison bat tale in years—that I’ve had a little trouble following, due in part to references to the Bat-past that I am not very familiar with. Nevertheless, it all made sense by the last page and continued my development from a Morrison hater to a Morrison fan. Yanick Paquette’s art won’t be for everyone—it feels very static and heavy—but I find that its uniqueness, its foreign flavor, adds to the “international” feel of this title. It’s also nice to see Morrison using Batwoman, who in my view is one of the best things to happen to the Bat-Universe in the past 10 years. It’s getting clearer (or cloudier) that all the “building a Bat-army” is actually leading to something. But I have no idea what. This title is a great ride—as great as Morrison’s New X-Men run.

NEW X-MEN BY GRANT MORRISON VOL. 1. Speaking of New X-Men, Marvel is reissuing the reprints of Morrison’s run, and volume one is brilliant. I confess, I’d never taken the time to get through this series before now, and I’m very happy I waited. Because reading it in a big chunk like this is great. Plus, so much meat! We meet the new insect-winged Angel (who is in the X-Men First Class movie) and Fantomex (now in X-Force); Magneto and 15,999,999 other mutants die; Professor X’s long lost sister comes back to literally haunt him; Emma Frost gets her diamond ability and begins seducing Scott; and we see the beginning of Phoenix bubbles. Truly amazing, must-read superhero stuff.

VENOM #2. So Kraven is in the savage land, and he’s huntin’ symbiotes. The art was great and story is good, but I can’t help feeling like there isn’t much to go with here. I feel like the pace is a little bit too slow in terms of the development of Flash Thompson as a character. I’m hoping we see a more personal issue soon, one that lets us into how Flash really feels about changing from being dependent on a wheelchair to being dependent on a psychotic alien being, and what the mental relationship is between him and his parasite. Lots and lots of action, though, and Moore’s art is just incredible. Can’t say enough about it.

Navigation

  • Mission Statement

    FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER.
  • FOLLOW ME ON TUMBLR http://www.tumblr.com/tumblelog/berkeleyplace WHAT THE HELL IS BERKELEY PLACE? "Berkeley Place" has been a blog since 2000.
  • Berkeley Place is also 6 blocks of Brooklyn real estate, emerging from Sackett St. and ending at Banana Hill, a small park that grows a foot each year from dog shit and the corpses of dead rats. Though its residents have gotten wealthier over the decades, Berkeley Place still houses folks of all backgrounds with interests in, well, everything.
  • WHAT THE HELL GOES ON HERE? Ekko reviews independent music, comic books, and whatever else interests him.
  • WHAT THE HELL IS INDIE MUSIC? An independent record label (or indie record label) is a record label operating without the funding of or outside the organizations of the major record labels. - Wikipedia.org That means they ain't in the RIAA, dude.

    HOW CAN I GET IN ON THIS?

    • Email me
      for the specifics but, basically:
    • I listen to all submissions of entire albums, not songs or compilations.
    • With rare exceptions I will not review material protected by the RIAA. So Sony, BMG, etc., don't start sending me crap. I'm not interested.
    • I don't listen to streams.
    • I won't read online comic-books. I may read .pdfs. I will read all hardcopy submissions.
    • I will review only submissions that I can recommend. I'm not here to do negative reviews.
    • Contact me to tell me to remove something. I'll take it down within 24 hours.
  • Comic Blog Elite
  • Tags!

  • Archives

  • I’M HYPED!

  • MMN

    Blog Directory Music Blogs Catlog Privacy Policy Quantcast Tag Blog Directory Submit Blog
  • 1.12.15/11.21.12

  • Copyright © 2009 Berkeley Place. Theme by THAT Agency but customised by TIM. Powered by WordPress.